Movie reviews

The Others: a house kept safe from daylight

Grace has good reasons to keep the house dark. The Others finds its unease where practical protection meets a mother's refusal to question what she knows.

Whimsical Woes editorial ·

Opening the curtains would be a sensible first response to a gloomy house. The Others makes that instinct dangerous. Its children cannot tolerate daylight, and the household rule requires one door to close before another opens. Darkness becomes something a responsible adult must maintain. That is a much more interesting predicament than simply being trapped somewhere creepy: keeping the children safe also means keeping the house difficult to see.

Alejandro Amenábar sets the story on Jersey in 1945, after the war, with Grace still waiting for her husband to return. Three new servants enter a home whose order is already under strain. The premise gives domestic management real stakes. A closed door has a purpose before it has a sinister suggestion. Grace's rules deserve to be understood, which makes questioning her a more complicated business.

A lesson that closes its own doors

The religious lesson reveals another sort of enclosure. Grace quizzes Anne and Nicholas about the afterlife, then tells them to close their eyes and imagine eternal punishment. A mother protecting vulnerable children also supplies them with an image of pain that has no end. The scene gives fear a lesson plan. There are correct answers to learn, and the cost of getting life wrong is made terrifyingly large.

That distinction matters to the film's treatment of authority. A useful rule about daylight does not make every explanation Grace offers equally reliable. Her confidence can feel protective and frightening within the same household. The conflict is worth attending to without reducing her to a cartoon tyrant or treating her beliefs as a complete account of religion. The unsettling thing is how easily care and certainty can borrow each other's voice.

Stay with the person trying to understand

Amenábar described the film's point of view as belonging mostly to Grace. That choice gives the restrictions an emotional center. We follow someone trying to interpret a situation she also has to manage. Keeping close to her does not require accepting every conclusion she reaches. It makes uncertainty expensive: she has responsibilities that cannot be put aside while she waits for a more satisfactory explanation of the house.

The quietness supports that attention. In his Nitrate Online interview, Amenábar explained his deliberate use of silence to build suspense. It is a good match for a story about protecting a small, restricted world. Listening becomes an activity, something requiring concentration. A film can make an audience work harder by allowing less noise to compete for its attention. Restraint has a job here beyond looking tasteful.

That approach will not satisfy everyone. Viewers looking for a sprawling supernatural mythology or frequent spectacle may find the narrow focus and measured investigation stifling. There is also a danger in treating a mystery only as a puzzle to finish: everything before the answer becomes a waiting room. The more rewarding question here is what a person does with uncertainty while other people depend on her.

For an artist, the strongest idea is the double purpose of a boundary. Give it a reason to exist that the audience can respect, then examine what else it prevents. Protection can limit understanding without becoming meaningless as protection. The Others gets lasting tension from that discomfort. A home can be carefully maintained, its rules faithfully observed, and still leave the person in charge unable to account for it.

Questions from the crypt

Why must the house in The Others stay dark?

The story establishes that Grace's children cannot be exposed to daylight. The closed-door routine is part of protecting them. This is a fictional premise, not a medical explanation of photosensitivity.

Does the film endorse Grace's lesson about the afterlife?

Her lesson establishes her authority and the fears she teaches her children. It should be read as characterization, rather than a guide to Catholic doctrine. The film questions the completeness of her understanding.

Is The Others (2001) an English-language film?

Yes. It was Alejandro Amenábar's first English-language feature, starring Nicole Kidman as Grace. This review concerns that original 2001 film.

Sources & further reading

Keep reading